Skip to content
SafetyRecord logoSafetyRecord
FIVE STAR COMMERCIAL ROOFING INC
$132,500
penalties
11
viol.
2
insp.

FIVE STAR COMMERCIAL ROOFING INC

211 E GARRO STREET, Plymouth, IN 46563NAICS 238160 Roofing Contractors

Inspections
2
Nov 2017 to Nov 2018 · 2 safety, 0 health
Violations
11
across 2 inspections
Penalties on record
$132,500
latest amounts in DOL records
By classification
Serious 8Willful 0Repeat 3Other 0

Having inspection records is common for businesses in regulated industries. Data and methodology

Inspection records

Nov 8, 2018Final Order RecordedFatalityFatality/Catastrophe (M) · Partial scope, Safety#343590113$126,0005 viol.

Inspection #343590113

Dates

Opened
Nov 8, 2018
Closing Conference Date
Feb 11, 2019
Final Order
Apr 3, 2019
Closed
No close date in inspection feed

Inspection

Advance Notice
No
Owner Type
Private
Union Status
No
Number of Employees
10
Related Activity
1 accident

Violations and Penalties

Total Violations
5
Violation Types
2 serious, 3 repeat
Initial Penalties
$120,000
Penalties on Record
$126,000
Site Address
2526 Western Ave, Plymouth, IN 46563
Industry
238160 Roofing Contractors

Fatality/Catastrophe Inspection: This inspection record is categorized as a fatality/catastrophe inspection in the DOL OSHA enforcement data.

OSHA's inspection feed still shows no close date for this record. However, the citation records tied to this inspection show final orders recorded through Apr 3, 2019.

Incident Investigation Summaries

Incident investigation summaries linked to this inspection through OSHA's accident and injury enforcement data. These summaries describe the reported incident. The enforcement outcome for the linked inspection is in the inspection details above.

FatalityNov 7, 2018

Employee is killed in fall thru skylight

Event: Fall (From Elevation)

Violations

Violation list (5 of 5 shown)
CitationStandardTypeInstancesExposedInitialCurrentAbatementContestFinal Order
010011926.501
Fall Protection - Duty to Have Fall Protection
OSHA citation code: 19260501 B04 I
Serious16$5,000$5,250Jun 15, 2019-Apr 3, 2019
010031926.502
Fall Protection Systems Criteria and Practices
OSHA citation code: 19260502 F02 IV
Serious16$5,000$5,250Jun 15, 2019-Apr 3, 2019
020011926.20
General Safety and Health Provisions
OSHA citation code: 19260020 B02
Repeat16$50,000$52,500Jun 15, 2019-Apr 3, 2019
020021926.501
Fall Protection - Duty to Have Fall Protection
OSHA citation code: 19260501 B10
Repeat16$50,000$52,500Jun 15, 2019-Apr 3, 2019
020031926.502
Fall Protection Systems Criteria and Practices
OSHA citation code: 19260502 H01 V
Repeat16$10,000$10,500Jun 15, 2019-Apr 3, 2019
Nov 8, 2017Final Order RecordedComplaint (B) · Partial scope, Safety#342786373$6,5006 viol.

Inspection #342786373

Dates

Opened
Nov 8, 2017
Closing Conference Date
Dec 27, 2017
Final Order
Mar 6, 2018
Closed
No close date in inspection feed

Inspection

Advance Notice
No
Owner Type
Private
Union Status
No
Number of Employees
4
Related Activity
1 complaint

Violations and Penalties

Total Violations
6
Violation Types
6 serious
Initial Penalties
$6,500
Penalties on Record
$6,500
Site Address
211 E Garro Street, Plymouth, IN 46563
Industry
238160 Roofing Contractors

Complaint Inspection: This inspection record is categorized as a complaint inspection in the DOL OSHA enforcement data. OSHA can open complaint-driven inspections after receiving safety or health complaints from workers or their representatives.

OSHA's inspection feed still shows no close date for this record. However, the citation records tied to this inspection show final orders recorded through Mar 6, 2018.

Violations

Violation list (6 of 6 shown)
CitationStandardTypeInstancesExposedInitialCurrentAbatementContestFinal Order
010011910.1200
Hazard Communication
OSHA citation code: 19101200 E01
Serious14$750$750Mar 28, 2018-Mar 6, 2018
010021926.20
General Safety and Health Provisions
OSHA citation code: 19260020 B01
Serious14$750$750Mar 28, 2018-Mar 6, 2018
010031926.20
General Safety and Health Provisions
OSHA citation code: 19260020 B02
Serious14$1,000$1,000Mar 28, 2018-Mar 6, 2018
010041926.21
Safety Training and Education
OSHA citation code: 19260021 B02
Serious14$750$750Mar 28, 2018-Mar 6, 2018
010051926.501
Fall Protection - Duty to Have Fall Protection
OSHA citation code: 19260501 B10
Serious14$2,500$2,500Mar 7, 2018-Mar 6, 2018
010061926.503
Fall Protection - Training Requirements
OSHA citation code: 19260503 A01
Serious14$750$750Mar 28, 2018-Mar 6, 2018
Inspections 1 to 2 of 2, newest first

Penalty amounts may differ from final amounts after settlement or judicial review. How to read these records

About these records

A company page groups inspections with the same normalized employer name, city and state; it is not a legal-entity identifier (how pages are grouped).

This page displays public OSHA enforcement data. Status text follows the DOL inspection record first and may include citation-level context when the inspection feed and citation records are out of sync. Penalty amounts shown reflect the latest penalty amounts on record in the DOL database and may differ from initial assessments or final amounts. This is not an official OSHA resource.

OSHA's public enforcement data does not publish a "guilty" or "not guilty" field for inspections. The closest outcome fields available are the citation counts, penalty amounts, contest dates, final-order dates, and the inspection close date shown on this page. How to interpret these status fields. How initial and current penalties are recorded.

OSHA may publish multiple citation rows in the same inspection with the same standard and penalty fields. Separate rows can still differ in OSHA metadata such as citation identifier, recorded instance count, exposed workers, or gravity value. Contest and Final Order columns show citation-level dates from OSHA's enforcement record. A dash means OSHA's record does not currently show that activity for the citation.

Source: U.S. Department of Labor OSHA incident investigation data (`osha_accident` + `osha_accident_injury`). Linked via `rel_insp_nr` to the inspection activity number (exact government key). Injury, body part, source and event values are OSHA's own codes. OSHA states that these fields are not coded according to the requirements under the Occupational Injury and Illness Classification System (OIICS). Only the values present in the OSHA record are listed; an incident with no value that resolves in OSHA's code table shows "Injury details not recorded". Where a record covers several people, each field lists every value recorded across them.

Understanding These Penalties

The maximum penalty for a serious violation in 2025 is $16,550 per violation. For willful violations, the range is $11,823 to $165,514. The current penalty column shows the latest amount on record in OSHA's database for each citation. When the current penalty differs from the initial penalty, OSHA's records show that the amount changed during the enforcement process, but this page does not determine the specific reason for each change. Penalty amounts are set by OSHA and adjusted annually for inflation.

Standards cited

1926.20General Safety and Health Provisions3 citations · $54,250
1926.501Fall Protection - Duty to Have Fall Protection3 citations · $60,250
1926.502Fall Protection Systems Criteria and Practices2 citations · $15,750

Industry comparison

Violations per inspection
This employer5.5
Industry average2.1
Penalties per inspection
This employer$66,250
Industry average$2,531

Specialty Trade Contractors, 552,207 employers with OSHA inspections. Arithmetic from DOL records.

BLS 2024 survey: roofing contractors reported 2.4 injuries and illnesses per 100 full-time workers (total recordable cases, national, private industry; relative standard error 9.7%; NAICS 23816 level). This is an industry-wide average from a federal survey, not a measurement of this establishment. Source

Other inspected employers in Plymouth, IN

All employers in Plymouth →